Do Stump Removal Chemicals Work? | | Yes, always | 4% | | In most cases | 12% | | In some cases | 41% | | No, never | 25% | | Not sure | 16% | | | | | Question: Do Stump Removal Chemicals Work? Top Answer (41% of 24 votes): In some cases.
Answer: In most cases
Explanation: Chemical stump removers speed up the natural decomposition process of a stump, turning it into a softer, more manageable material.
But are they safe? No, stump removal chemicals are not safe and can be harmful to humans, pets, and the environment:
Common chemicals
Some common and effective chemicals used in stump removers include:
Potassium nitrate: A common and effective chemical that provides more oxygen for bacteria that break down wood.
Sodium hydroxide: A liquid chemical that's mixed with water in a 2:1 ratio.
Rock salt: A chemical that's mixed with water and applied to the most affected parts of the stump.
Magnesium sulfate: A chemical that's mixed with water and applied to the most affected parts of the stump
A safer alternative to chemical stump removal is girdling, which involves removing the protective layer of bark and some living tree cells. However, this method can take a long time to take effect and can leave the tree vulnerable to pests. | | J&K Contracting | Answer: No, never
Explanation: Stump chemicals can kill and dry out the stump. Removal is still required by mechanical means. | | AMERICAN STUMPBUSTERS | Answer: Not sure
Explanation: Never test it | | M & S Tree Service | | | ProMatcher | Answer: In some cases
Explanation: depending on the application | | Haulbrooke Inc | Answer: Not sure
Explanation: Depends, type of stump, wetness, hazards to wildlife or pets. Time | | TORRISON TREE SERVICE | Answer: No, never
Explanation: Approximately 25% of the stumps I've ground were previously assaulted by the homeowner before I got there. I've seen people run their chainsaw into the dirt to try to cut roots, go at it with an axe, the use of chemicals, fire and attempted digging of the stump. Of all of them, the chemicals are what I see the most. If they worked I wouldn't be getting called to those locations. | | Eager Beaver Stump Grinding | | | ProMatcher | Answer: In most cases
Explanation: With propper use. | | Lance Fink Tree Falling/Removal | Answer: In some cases
Explanation: For immediate results, we recommend Grinding the stump, if that's not an option then you can poison the stump. | | Timberworx Tree and Landscaping | Answer: Not sure
Explanation: Have never had any experience with them. | | Down To Dirt Stump Grinding |
|